When it comes to planning a wedding in the picturesque setting of Fort Myers Beach, Florida, few details are as important—or as memorable—as the food. Nestled on the Gulf Coast with stunning sunsets and soft sand, Fort Myers Beach offers the perfect backdrop for your special day. But between flowers, photography, and venue costs, catering can quickly eat up your budget.
Luckily, Fort Myers Beach is home to an impressive selection of affordable wedding caterers who bring both flavor and finesse to your celebration—without blowing your wedding budget. Whether you’re dreaming of fresh coastal fare, Southern comfort classics, or elegant plated dinners, you’ll find local caterers who combine delicious cuisine with exceptional value.
Below is a guide to some of the best budget-friendly wedding caterers serving Fort Myers Beach.
G3 Catering
G3 Catering is a top-rated local favorite known for its culinary creativity and customer-first approach. From intimate beachside ceremonies to full-scale ballroom receptions, G3 offers catering packages tailored to your needs and budget.
Why They Stand Out
Wide range of customizable menus: BBQ, Italian, vegan-friendly, and more
Buffet-style, plated, and cocktail hour options
Known for punctuality and professional service
Affordable rates without sacrificing presentation or taste
Couples love G3 for their flexibility and personalized service—two things that are invaluable when planning a wedding with cost in mind.
Black Tie Catering Company
Located in Fort Myers but widely serving weddings across Southwest Florida, Black Tie Catering provides gourmet-style meals at surprisingly accessible prices. Their name might suggest luxury, but their pricing is refreshingly approachable.
Key Features
Menu options include surf & turf, Mediterranean, American classics
Full-service or drop-off catering available
Strong reputation with wedding venues in the Fort Myers Beach area
Known for elegant setups and flavorful dishes
Perfect for couples who want a classy experience without the upscale price tag, Black Tie blends taste with value seamlessly.
Artichoke and Company
With over 30 years of experience in the event catering industry, Artichoke and Company brings both sophistication and flexibility to wedding dining. Though they cater high-end events, their pricing can be surprisingly budget-friendly, especially for smaller weddings or weekday events.
What to Expect
Cuisine ranging from modern American to global flavors
Full wedding coordination available with catering packages
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options
Attentive service staff and custom presentation styles
Their experienced team is known for helping couples create tailored menus that reflect their love story—without overextending the budget.
Personal Touch Catering
Personal Touch Catering lives up to its name by offering truly customized catering experiences. Ideal for couples wanting that homemade feel paired with professional execution, this Fort Myers Beach staple is a go-to for budget-conscious weddings.
Highlights
Offers everything from Southern-style BBQs to upscale plated meals
Rentals for linens, flatware, and décor available
Warm and friendly staff, often praised in reviews
Custom pricing options based on guest count and menu
This caterer is ideal for laid-back, family-style weddings that don’t compromise on taste or hospitality.
KJ’s Fresh Market Catering
For eco-conscious couples who want flavorful and affordable meals, KJ’s Fresh Market Catering brings farm-to-table goodness to your reception. Their fresh, local ingredients and transparent pricing make them a standout in Fort Myers Beach.
Why Couples Choose Them
Seasonal and locally sourced menu items
Vegetarian, vegan, and allergy-conscious menu options
Great for outdoor weddings and beach receptions
Drop-off or full-service catering available based on budget
Their clear tiered pricing structure makes it easy to build a delicious meal plan that aligns with your wedding funds.
Renee’s Southern Kitchen
If you’re dreaming of a relaxed, Southern-inspired celebration, Renee’s Southern Kitchen might be your perfect match. This beloved local gem serves up hearty, flavorful dishes your guests will rave about for months.
Popular Dishes Include
Buttermilk fried chicken, slow-cooked pulled pork, and creamy mac n’ cheese
Buffet or family-style options ideal for rustic weddings
Warm, welcoming staff who treat you like family
Budget-friendly packages with generous portions
They’re particularly popular for beachfront weddings and barn-style receptions, where casual elegance and soul food go hand in hand.
Tips for Booking an Affordable Wedding Caterer in Fort Myers Beach
Book Early
Fort Myers Beach is a popular wedding destination, especially from October through May. Booking your caterer early can help you avoid high-season price hikes and limited availability.
Choose Off-Peak Dates
Saturdays in season are always in high demand. If you’re flexible, consider a Friday evening or Sunday brunch wedding. Many caterers offer discounts for weekday or off-peak bookings.
Consider Hybrid Catering Styles
You can often save money by mixing service styles—such as buffet for the main course and plated for starters. Drop-off options are also available for couples with smaller guest counts.
Be Upfront About Your Budget
Don’t hesitate to share your budget range with potential caterers. Most are willing to offer a few pricing tiers or suggest creative swaps (like fewer hors d'oeuvres or more filling mains) to keep costs low.
Ask About Package Deals
Some caterers also provide bartending, dessert tables, and event rentals. Choosing an all-in-one provider can simplify planning and reduce overall costs.
Final Thoughts
A beautiful wedding doesn’t have to come with a sky-high catering bill. In Fort Myers Beach, a variety of affordable wedding caterers offer flavorful, professional, and memorable dining experiences that fit a wide range of budgets.
Whether you’re drawn to the coastal elegance of G3 Catering, the rustic charm of Renee’s Southern Kitchen, or the fresh approach of KJ’s Fresh Market, there’s a local expert ready to help you serve unforgettable meals on your big day.
Start by narrowing down your style, then book tastings or consultations early to ensure you get the best vendor for your vision. Your dream beach wedding with budget-friendly catering is entirely possible—with a little research and the right local partner.
